Restoration logo
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
  • NEWS
  • PRODUCTS
  • EDUCATION
  • TOPICS
  • BUSINESS
  • BUYER'S GUIDE
  • VIDEOS
  • INFOCENTER
  • THE EXPERIENCE
  • EMAG
  • SIGN UP
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • PRODUCTS
  • New Products & Technologies
  • Submit Your Product
  • Interactive Product Spotlights
  • EDUCATION
  • KnowHow.
  • Podcasts
  • Trade Shows & Expos
  • Training & Certification
  • Webinars
  • Whitepapers
  • TOPICS
  • Water Damage
  • Fire & Smoke Damage
  • Mold
  • Contamination
  • Odor
  • Contents
  • Architecture
  • Catastrophe
  • Cleaning
  • BUSINESS
  • Managing Your Business
  • Insurance/Legal Matters
  • VIDEOS
  • Ask Annissa
  • Ask the Expert
  • Ironclad Marketing Minute
  • TradeTalks
  • Video Channel
  • INFOCENTER
  • Mold and Mycotoxins
  • THE EXPERIENCE
  • Conference & Exhibition
  • Convention & Trade Show
  • R&R Special Issue
  • EMAG
  • eMagazine
  • Archive Issues
  • Contact
  • Advertise
Restoration logo
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Restoration logo
  • NEWS
  • PRODUCTS
    • New Products & Technologies
    • Submit Your Product
    • Interactive Product Spotlights
  • EDUCATION
    • KnowHow.
    • Podcasts
    • Trade Shows & Expos
    • Training & Certification
    • Webinars
    • Whitepapers
  • TOPICS
    • Water Damage
    • Fire & Smoke Damage
    • Mold
    • Contamination
    • Odor
    • Contents
    • Architecture
    • Catastrophe
    • Cleaning
  • BUSINESS
    • Managing Your Business
    • Insurance/Legal Matters
  • BUYER'S GUIDE
  • VIDEOS
    • Ask Annissa
    • Ask the Expert
    • Ironclad Marketing Minute
    • TradeTalks
    • Video Channel
  • INFOCENTER
    • Mold and Mycotoxins
  • THE EXPERIENCE
    • Conference & Exhibition
    • Convention & Trade Show
    • R&R Special Issue
  • EMAG
    • eMagazine
    • Archive Issues
    • Contact
    • Advertise
  • SIGN UP
Insurance/Legal Matters in Restoration

Unprepared Restoration Contractor is Dealt Devastating Blow at Trial

Litigating restoration cases can be a minefield for the inexperienced

By Edward H. Cross Esq., "The Restoration Lawyer"
man in courtroom
water spilling on floor
mock trial
tornado
High winds can aerosolize dust and soil, which can be captured in wind-driven rain.
man in courtroom
water spilling on floor
mock trial
tornado
November 1, 2013

On September 4, 2013, the mock trial of Moore v. Heatman went forward at “Cross-Examination: The Live Courtroom Experience” at The Experience Convention in Las Vegas, with the Honorable Judge James Dread (played by Jim Holland) presiding. 

The Plaintiff, William (“Bill”) Moore (played by Ron Reese), a licensed general contractor, was represented by John Dewey (played by yours truly) of the Law Offices of Dewey, Scroom and Howe. The Defendant and Cross-Complainant, Chaz Heatman (played by Charlie Cressy), represented himself.

Moore filed the lawsuit against Heatman alleging $60,000 due for services rendered at Heatman’s home. The suit was based on two alternative theories of recovery: breach of contract and quantum meruit. 

Heatman filed a cross-complaint against Mr. Moore alleging damages arising from deficient workmanship in the sum of $50,000. He alleged that Moore used biocides without Heatman’s consent and that it would cost $20,000 to remove the biocide residue and clean the house. He also alleged that Moore negligently cut carpet and added new seams, and that it would cost $30,000 to replace the carpet in two bedrooms and a hallway.

Mr. Heatman lived alone in a modest 2,000 square foot single-family residence in Atlantic City, New Jersey. On September 4, 2010, a major storm struck and the house was damaged by wind-driven rain which intruded into two bedrooms and a bathroom.  There was carpet in the bedrooms and hallway and tile floor in the bathroom.

The property was slab-on-grade construction, with a stucco exterior and drywall interior with vinyl wallpaper throughout. The third bedroom, kitchen and living room did not get wet from this loss. The house was built in 1990 and still had its original carpet.

The home was insured by Gamblers Atlantic Insurance Co. Mr. Heatman made a claim with Gamblers Atlantic on September 4, 2010, the date of the loss. Mr. Heatman waited to hire a contractor until his insurance company inspected the loss. Gamblers first responded on September 10, 2010, with an inspection by adjuster Joe Canuck (played by Darren Hudema).

Mr. Heatman signed a Work Authorization with Mr. Moore on September 10, 2010, which stated that he was hiring Mr. Moore to restore the property to its pre-loss condition, and that Mr. Heatman was directing his insurance company to send all payments for Mr. Moore’s work directly to Mr. Moore. The authorization also stated Heatman would be responsible for charges not paid by insurance. There were no other principal legal terms in the authorization. It did not state the cost of the work and Mr. Moore did not provide Mr. Heatman with a price list. Mr. Heatman believed Mr. Moore would accept the insurance proceeds as payment in full, and did not ask for the price.

Mr. Moore began work on September 10, 2010, installing 11 air movers, four dehumidifiers and three air scrubbers, which ran for eight days each. After he turned on the drying equipment on September 10, he removed baseboard, which revealed mold. He removed drywall that was too wet to dry, which also revealed mold within the wall cavities, which he remediated following industry standards. He only worked in the three rooms that got wet. He completed the repairs on December 10, 2010 and billed $70,000 for the work the same day.

 

IS WIND-DRIVEN RAIN CATEGORY 3 WATER?

Moore contends that the application of a biocide was justified because the water fell within the IICRC’s “Category 3” for grossly-contaminated water. Water damage restoration consultant Edward X. Spirt (played by Barry Costa) testified on Moore’s behalf that restorers must err on the side of caution and that wind-driven rain should be considered Category 3 water in the absence of compelling evidence supporting a different categorization.

Spirt contended that high winds can aerosolize dust and soil, which can be captured in wind-driven rain, along with the fertilizers, pesticides, heavy metals and other contaminants contained in the dust and soil. He offered an illustration of a tornado over a farm. It appeared to be drawing manure into the air and therefore, the rain. 

Spirt testified that the water in this case should also be considered Category 3 because it penetrated the walls and sat for six days before drying efforts began, which likely led to a proliferation of bacteria and fungi, although no samples were taken.

Thadeus (“Thad”) Tomuch (played by Jeff Bishop) is a licensed restoration contractor but has not performed actual restoration work in a decade. He now works as a professional consultant and was hired as an expert witness for this case by Gamblers Atlantic. He prepared a competitive bid allowing $5,000 for drying (based on three days of drying) and $15,000 for repairs and nothing else. He disallowed mold remediation.

Tomuch testified that Spirt’s illustration of alleged airborne manure is actually fire retardant dropped into the eye of the storm. Moreover, Tomuch contended the illustration is irrelevant because there was no tornado in this case.

 

WHAT IS THE STANDARD OF CARE FOR THE USE OF BIOCIDES?

Tomuch pointed out that the use of biocides is discouraged by the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH), and that they pose unnecessary potential health hazards to occupants. He believes the proper approach is to assume water is Category 1 and work up into higher categories from there, as warranted by the known facts of the loss. He testified that the intent of the IICRC standards is to categorize water based on actual evidence, rather than speculation, and that here, there was no data to show that the water was actually contaminated. He opined that the water at issue in this case should have been treated as Category 1. The jury disagreed, and found that the water was Category 3. 

The expert for the insurance company testified that if the water had been Category 3, as Moore alleged, then the carpet should have been removed and the insurance company should not have been billed for the cost to dry the carpet. At trial, Moore was caught off guard by that argument, and it took on great significance to the jury. To make matters worse, Moore did not have thorough records of the atmospheric conditions during the drying. 

In an effort to do damage control at trial, counsel for Moore belatedly suggested that the water in the wall cavities was more contaminated than the water in the carpet and that the walls should have been addressed as Category 3 water. The jury found that the carpet should have been removed. It found that Moore violated the standard of care by failing to obtain the informed written consent of the homeowner to apply biocides. However, it found that it was not a violation of the standard of care to apply biocides under these circumstances. The jury awarded the homeowner nothing on his cross-complaint, which alleged $20,000 in expenses to decontaminate the house to remove biocide residue. 

 

VERDICT FOR HOMEOWNER ON BREACH OF CONTRACT

Every legal claim has a basic set of elements which must be proven in order to prevail. Four out of five is not enough. In order to prevail on claim of breach of contract, the plaintiff must prove, among other things, that he performed all of his duties under the contract, except those that were waived or excused. 

In this case, the jury found for the contractor on all the elements of breach of contract - except that he performed all of his duties under the contract. The work authorization did not specify what was to be done with the carpet, but the jury inferred a contractual duty to remove the carpet. So a crucial element of the contract claim was not met. As a result, the contractor recovered zero on his contract claim. 

 

VERDICT FOR CONTRACTOR ON HOMEOWNER’S CROSS-COMPLAINT

Conflict arose between Mr. Heatman and Mr. Moore regarding cuts and seams Mr. Moore made in the carpet in the two bedrooms. Mr. Heatman claimed the seams were visible and unnecessary. Mr. Moore claims the seams are invisible and were necessary to float the carpet during the drying. At least one juror believed that seams are never guaranteed to be invisible.

The homeowner failed to produce evidence that the house needed to be decontaminated due to biocide residence. His claim for $20,000 to replace the carpet was rejected by the jury because it determined the carpet needed to be removed anyway because it had been contaminated with Category 3 water. As result, the homeowner was awarded zero on his cross-complaint.

 

VERDICT FOR CONTRACTOR ON QUANTUM MERUIT

Quantum meruit is intended to prevent the unjust enrichment of the owner where she received a benefit and did not pay for it when fairness required that payment be made. It is the saving grace for many restorers because work authorizations often bear no resemblance to a payment contract. Quantum meruit can be used to address situations where no contract exists or where a contract exists but for some reason is unenforceable. In that event, a court may imply a contract to avoid an unjust result. These contracts are called “quasi contracts.”

Quantum meruit also describes a method used to determine the exact amount owed to a person. A court may measure this amount either by determining how much the defendant has benefited from the transaction. The law abhors forfeiture.

Here, the jury found for the contractor on the quantum meruit claim, but dealt him a devastating blow on the monetary award. It found that the reasonable value of the services he rendered was only $40,000 - a reduction of $30,000 dollars off Bill Moore’s invoice. In effect, the jury gave the homeowner the demolition, drying and biocides for free - and a $10,000 bonus to boot. Since the contractor had already been paid $10,000, the net result of the case was a $30,000 verdict for the contractor.

 

VIOLENCE IN THE COURTROOM

John Dewey, the arrogant lawyer for the contractor, strenuously objected to the court’s findings and moved to set aside the verdict on grounds that it was not supported by the weight of the evidence. The motion was denied. But when Judge Dread adjourned the matter, Mr. Dewey continued arguing. Judge Dread warned Mr. Dewey that he would be held in contempt if he did not cease. Not heeding the warning, Mr. Dewey continued and was held in contempt. He erupted in response to the contempt finding and the judge ordered that he be taken into custody. But he resisted arrest. He pushed the bailiff, and was badly beaten with plastic baton and dragged out of the courtroom by his feet.

 

LESSONS LEARNED

This is a classic example of how mishandled cases can lead to unfair - or even unintended - results. It also illustrates the risks inherent in our legal system. The prudent restorer will carefully document all the pertinent events on a job, what happened, where, when and why. Litigating restoration cases can be a minefield for the inexperienced. Prudent counsel for restorers will thoughtfully consider the ramifications of each argument, such as arguing that water was Category 3. At the root of every successful restoration case is thorough preparation.

 

 

 SPECIAL THANKS: The author would like to extend a special thanks to Ron Reese, Jeff Bishop, Barry Costa, Charlie Cressy, Jim Holland, Darren Hudema, O.P. Almaraz, and Jim Milne for their excellent performance as cast members in Cross-Examination Live.   

KEYWORDS: restoration restoration contractors restoration contracts restoration education restoration regulation

Share This Story

Looking for a reprint of this article?
From high-res PDFs to custom plaques, order your copy today!

Ed cross headshot

Ed Cross, “The Restoration Lawyer,” represents restorers nationwide from offices in Palm Desert, California and Honolulu, Hawaii. His firm drafts restoration contracts, collects money for restorers and represents them in litigation. He is the Restoration Contractor Advocate for the Restoration Industry Association. He can be reached at (760) 773-4002 or by email at Ed@EdCross.com. For information about how to document a file to accelerate collections, visit EdCross.com/collections. 

Recommended Content

JOIN TODAY
To unlock your recommendations.

Already have an account? Sign In

  • mold remediation

    Fighting Mold and Bacteria Damage

    Successful mold remediation can be multidisciplinary,...
    Cleaning and Sanitation
    By: Josh Woolen
  • certifications and licenses for restoration professionals

    Certifications and Licenses Every Restoration Company Needs

    Restoration companies need to make sure they have the...
    Restoration Training/Education
    By: Sharon Elzarat
  • a wall covered in moss and fungus

    Zero Tolerance for Toxic Molds: Essential Steps for Successful Remediation

    Understanding the importance of zero tolerance for toxic...
    Mold Remediation
    By: Michael A. Pinto CSP, SMS, CMP, RTPE, FLS, ERS and Kendra Seymour
You must login or register in order to post a comment.

Report Abusive Comment

Subscribe For Free!
  • eNewsletter
  • Online Registration
  • Subscription Customer Service
  • Manage My Preferences

Inside RIA: Restoration Strategy & Vision

Inside RIA: Restoration Strategy & Vision

Ask The Expert - From the Unknown to Making a Difference: AJ and Becky's Journey

Ask The Expert - From the Unknown to Making a Difference: AJ and Becky's Journey

Ask The Expert - Transforming Business Operations: Insights from Leighton Healey

Ask The Expert - Transforming Business Operations: Insights from Leighton Healey

Ask The Expert: Unlocking Efficiency in Water Damage Restoration

Ask The Expert: Unlocking Efficiency in Water Damage Restoration

More Videos

Popular Stories

Ask the Expert: Unlocking Efficiency in Water Damage Restoration

Unlocking Efficiency in Water Damage Restoration

Ask the Expert: Catastrophe Panel - Back to the Basics Part 1

Catastrophe Panel – Back to the Basics Part 1

Jon-Don and Aramsco

Aramsco Acquires Jon-Don Assets to Ensure Seamless Service and Support for Customers

Submit Your New Product/Technology to R&R!

Would you like to promote a new restoration, remediation or cleaning product/technology with Restoration & Remediation? Fill out the question below to start your submission:

Events

September 3, 2025

The Experience Convention and Trade Show

The Experience Convention & Trade Show logoJoin us in Las Vegas for The Experience Convention & Trade Show, the leading event for cleaning, restoration, and remediation pros, packed with hands-on demos, expert speakers, and high-impact networking. Happening September 3–5, 2025 at Caesars Forum—this is where the industry comes to learn, connect, and grow!

View All Submit An Event

Poll

Restoration Services

What restoration/remediation service do you prioritize most?
View Results Poll Archive

Products

The Cleaning, Restoration, Inspection, and Safety Glossary

The Cleaning, Restoration, Inspection, and Safety Glossary

The Cleaning, Restoration, Inspection, and Safety Glossary.

See More Products

Related Articles

  • Why DON’T You Pay for That?

    Cross-Examination: Who Is in Charge of Setting Restoration Prices?

    See More
  • Are you getting screwed by your lawyer?

    Getting Screwed By Your Lawyer?

    See More
  • Restoration Advocacy Report

    Restoration Advocacy Report #1

    See More

Related Products

See More Products
  • CONTENTS_SUCCESS_BOOK-(2)-1.gif

    The Contents Restoration Success eBook! (PDF download)

  • CRIS.gif

    The Cleaning, Restoration, Inspection, and Safety Glossary

See More Products

Events

View AllSubmit An Event
  • May 8, 2025

    Top Legal Tools Every Restoration Contractor Should Understand

    On Demand Explore the most effective legal tools available to restoration contractors. Discover how these resources can enhance credibility with customers, provide strategic options for addressing delayed invoices, and help determine when to seek legal counsel.
View AllSubmit An Event

Related Directories

  • Rytech Restoration of the Midlands

    No one plans for the destruction caused by water, fire or mold, but when it happens, the team at Rytech Restoration of The Midlands is here to help. Our certified specialists provide 24/7 emergency service to get you and your Columbia SC home or business back to normal as quickly as possible. From residential homes to commercial buildings, we specialize in mold remediation, water damage restoration, and fire and smoke damage cleanup. Our live specialists are ready to answer your questions and dispatch a local specialist to your door. Schedule a free inspection and estimate today!
×
High winds can aerosolize dust and soil, which can be captured in wind-driven rain.

Stay ahead of the curve with our eNewsletters.

Get the latest industry updates tailored your way.

JOIN TODAY!
  • RESOURCES
    • Advertise
    • Contact Us
    • Directories
    • Store
    • Want More
    • Submit a Press Release
  • SIGN UP TODAY
    • Create Account
    • eNewsletters
    • Customer Service
    • Manage Preferences
  • SERVICES
    • Reprints
    • Marketing Services
    • Market Research
    • List Rental
    • Survey/Respondent Access
  • STAY CONNECTED
    • LinkedIn
    • Facebook
    • YouTube
    • X (Twitter)
  • PRIVACY
    • PRIVACY POLICY
    • TERMS & CONDITIONS
    • DO NOT SELL MY PERSONAL INFORMATION
    • PRIVACY REQUEST
    • ACCESSIBILITY

Copyright ©2025. All Rights Reserved BNP Media.

Design, CMS, Hosting & Web Development :: ePublishing

Restoration logo
search
cart
facebook twitter linkedin youtube
  • Sign In
  • Create Account
  • Sign Out
  • My Account
Restoration logo
  • NEWS
  • PRODUCTS
    • New Products & Technologies
    • Submit Your Product
    • Interactive Product Spotlights
  • EDUCATION
    • KnowHow.
    • Podcasts
    • Trade Shows & Expos
    • Training & Certification
    • Webinars
    • Whitepapers
  • TOPICS
    • Water Damage
    • Fire & Smoke Damage
    • Mold
    • Contamination
    • Odor
    • Contents
    • Architecture
    • Catastrophe
    • Cleaning
  • BUSINESS
    • Managing Your Business
    • Insurance/Legal Matters
  • BUYER'S GUIDE
  • VIDEOS
    • Ask Annissa
    • Ask the Expert
    • Ironclad Marketing Minute
    • TradeTalks
    • Video Channel
  • INFOCENTER
    • Mold and Mycotoxins
  • THE EXPERIENCE
    • Conference & Exhibition
    • Convention & Trade Show
    • R&R Special Issue
  • EMAG
    • eMagazine
    • Archive Issues
    • Contact
    • Advertise
  • SIGN UP